Experimenting: a month of living primal
Sunday, December 12th, 2010Let’s just face it: I’m a large guy. Always have been really (if you don’t count the age 15-19 when I was very serious about basketball). I know that part of this is because of genes, but most because of bad eating habits. I seriously changed a lot of those habits and it shows. I’ve lost around 14 kg in 2 years, due to eating healthier and being more active. But I’ve stalled somewhat in the last couple of months when it comes to the weight loss and despite experimenting with foods it just didn’t feel right somehow.
Then some time ago I stumbled upon the site of Mark Sisson. A former pro marathon runner and triathlete, he wrote a book called The Primal Blueprint where he outlines a lifestyle that promises better health, loss of weight/weight management and a good eating experience. Sounded to good to be true at first to me, but the more I read his site, the more it made sense to me. So I ordered the book, read it cover to cover and decided to give it a month to see if it would stick.
If you want the elevator pitch to what primal living is, it’s this: eat what you want, as long as they are no sugars, corn/grain based foods, legumes or artificial. Move around a lot at a slow pace, do 2 weight-lifting (bodyweight) and one sprint session a week and enjoy. Sisson gets more detailed in his book of course (using his 10 laws) but that’s the gist of it. So how did I fare during this month?
The Good:
- The promise of weightloss was true: I lost 3.1 kg this month. The change in my diet was mostly cutting out the corn/grain based and sugary foods (but not entirely: more on that later) and keeping a food dairy. The latter helped me understand foods more and how you could fill your day with foods that would give you everything you needed.
- No hunger feeling.
- Great recipes for lunch and diner.
- Feeling better. This is of course very subjective, but I seem to sleep better, have more energy and just have that better overall feeling.
- I can still have my Meatless Mondays. Although eating meat is highly recommended due to its protein value, you can still go all veggie or vegetarian if you want to.
- The 80/20 rule. We’re all humans and despite you may strive for 100% success it’s certain you’re going to fall off the wagon at some point. Sissons solution for this is his view that you have to aim for perfect, but you need to get it right at least 80% of the time.
The Bad
- It seems I have the backbone of a sea horse when it comes to sweets and italian pastry, which are pretty much no-no’s in primal living. During this month, I’ve indulged myself in eating chocolate, chocolate covered “pepernoten” and pizza (although I’ve discovered there’s a primal alternative) on a pretty regular basis. If I didn’t I may have even better results, so I’ve taken it upon myself to better myself in this area.
- Social situations make living primal difficult. When you’re out and about with friends there’s often some kind of eating involved. Maybe that’s having a slice of pizza, grab a burger, eat some pasta. All of those are not at all considered primal. You quickly realize that eating primal in restaurants is a tough task. You also don’t want to be a hassle to your friends turning down every option they come up with. Luckily there’s the 80/20 rule, but it can be a bit of a problem
- Breakfast. Most of the breakfast recipes I came across are egg-related. I don’t mind the occasional egg, but not every morning. Solution to this have been that I skip breakfast (if I’m not hungry that is) on most days I don’t have to work or eat fruit. But it would be nice to have some other form of breakfast.
Miscellaneous
- Part of the Primal Blueprint is the exercising part where you move alot at a slow pace, do 2 weight and 1 sprint session a week. I haven’t implemented that at all. These sessions are designed to take little time but high impact (max 20 minutes) and the book provides evidence that chronic cardio is not always benificial. The moving at a slow pace is highly implemented: cycling to work, going hiking, walking to stores etc, etc. The weight lifting part I’ve done maybe once or twice. The routines are straight forward enough and consist of body weight exercises but as with many weight exercises they just don’t excite me. The sprinting exercise for me is my weekly Spinning session. According to Sisson it’s part of the chronic cardio and should be done sparingly, but I enjoy that way too much to give it up. I do want to change my approach to this though and am planning to give that weight training a second change.
- Primal Community. There’s a large community when it comes to primal living and you can find all kinds of sites who give you tips and recipes for expanding/simplify your experience. This has been of great help.
Primal living goes against common knowledge on a various subjects of what is considered healthy living. This could scare people off. Although for me it still is a bit of a work in progress as you can conclude from my story above, I enjoy primal living extremely. The benefits for me greatly outweigh the downsides for which I think there are solutions I just haven’t found/thought of. I can see myself living this way for a long time.